"There are 9,388 graves in the cemetery, most of them in the form of white Latin crosses, a handful of them Stars of David commemorating Jewish American service members. As antisemitism rises again in Europe, they seem somehow more conspicuous." ---Roger Cohen, The New York Times. "D-Day at 80" -- June 6, 2024. https://www.nytimes.com/2024/06/06/world/europe/dday-80th-anniversary-veterans-remember.html Marianne Vecsey noticed the same thing, back in the mid-70s, when we drove with our young children to Normandy, in the sweet damp spring. Part of Marianne's ancestry goes back a thousand years to Normandy, but this was not about us. This was about the Allies who died during the invasion, now 80 years ago. We live in New York; we tend to notice stars amidst the crosses. "You hear the number, but when you stand there, and see the graves with crosses and stars, it sinks in. It's stunning, actually," Marianne said on D-Day 2024. Roger Cohen had the same reaction. Of course he did. Roger is one of the greatest Times writers of any generation -- fearless, perceptive, the voice of the underdog, the champion of the fallen. I've spent great times with Roger running around Germany during the 2006 World Cup or watching him suffer for his Chelsea F.C., in some New York pub. I've read his poignant tribute to his mother, to all who suffer, in his 2015 book, "The Girl From Human Street." https://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/feb/22/the-girl-from-human-street-review-roger-cohen-memoir-motherodyssey-of-loss I miss him in New York -- Brooklyn, to be specific, but now he is right where he should be, in the middle of it, as Paris Bureau Chief, preparing his masterful text for the 80th "anniversary." Marianne and I and "the kids" made the same pilgrimmage north from Paris, borrowing a friend's chugging sedan, heading toward the tangy air of salt water, toward Mt. St. Michel. (I had learned to love Mt. St. Michel, reading Richard Halliburton in grade school.) Now we were there, in a scruffy little gite near the beaches, in a spring so damp that sheets did not dry on the line. We saw the Bayeux Tapestry, of course we did, and then we headed to the beach. Funny, as we sat atop one of the sandy cliffs, we heard distinct German voices behind us -- three cars, three sporty couples, no longer the enemy, just modern Europeans on spring holiday, to see the Normandy beaches, the landing now three decades in the past. We took in the logistics of that landing, what it was like to be in those landing craft. The only person I knew who had been in one of those boats was Lawrence Peter Berra of St. Louis; but Yogi never talked about it, just as his teammate Ralph Houk barely alluded to his battlefield commission at the Battle of the Bulge. Veterans don't talk much. Marianne learned that when she was a lifeguard at a village pool on Long Island. Some of the older town workers had been in the war, but never shared details. Now it is 80 years, and centenarians will talk, particularly if a master journalist like Roger Cohen asks the right questions, the right way. People talk to Roger. Read his words; look at the photos. Marianne stored the visual memories, the visceral impact, of the Stars and the Crosses. She's an artist -- has a lifetime of paintings out there.
We loved our April in Paris, staying in a sous-sol in Neuilly-sur-Seine. The Metro. The Louvre. The Bois. Then we came home and resumed normal lives, and one night Marianne waited for the family to go to sleep, and she painted her geometric tribute. This month Roger Cohen has been, as always, in the right place, recalling the Canadians, the Europeans, the Americans, who stayed behind, in Normandy.
Alan D. Levine
6/6/2024 05:17:55 pm
My late first wife's father was in the Corps of Engineers, which meant he was in the first wave to hit the beach that day. He then walked across a good part of Europe until he got trench foot so bad he had to be flown to an Army hospital in Denver to recover. I think he suffered from PTSD for the rest of his life. He, also, barely talked about the war.
GV
6/6/2024 10:05:07 pm
Alan, lot of people carried damage...many of them silently.
Ed Martin
6/6/2024 05:26:25 pm
Peggy and I traveled to Normandy from Paris years ago. I wanted to see the Cathedral ar Rouen, because I had seen Monet’s paintings, a dozen or so in different light.
Ed Martin
6/6/2024 05:36:34 pm
Error, hit submit by accident.
GV
6/6/2024 10:09:07 pm
Ed, sometimes, officers know what is in store for the troops. The equation of war. I took three years of ROTC in college....studied tactics at Gettysburg or Normandy.
Ina Selden
6/6/2024 05:29:39 pm
Lucky you to have spent time with Roger Cohen. Maury and I are about to listen for a second time to Cohen on the Brian Lehrer (another 5-star reporter) Show. Cohen brings his considerable erudition to the war in Gaza. To find the interview Google Brian Lehrer Richard cohen interview
GV
6/6/2024 10:11:13 pm
Ina, grazie. Lo cercherò. G
Altenir Silva
6/6/2024 06:38:44 pm
Dear George: I think it was a strange feeling sitting down on this beach and hearing a German accent behind you. Thank the Lord it was just modern Europeans on spring holiday. Still, I think being on this beach must have been a strange experience.
GV
6/6/2024 10:15:04 pm
Altenir, I can't say I was jarred by the presence. Lot of time had passed....about 6-7 years later, I was covering an international meeting of "youth of the world" at Taize, France.....very ecumenical, multi-lingual....and met some very thoughtful German clergy and youth....GV
Altenir Silva
6/7/2024 06:22:40 am
I thought about the scenery. I think we would feel a weird feeling being on that beach and thinking about what had happened. The Germans are as animated as Brazilians. What they do in soccer is amazing. It is not 'jogo bonito' (the beautiful game), but it is efficient.
Walter Schwartz
6/6/2024 08:35:19 pm
My Mom had twin cousins, Ron and Don, who were about 18 when they were sent off to Europe to fight for our country and democracy. They were placed in the same unit and were captured and taken prisoner by the Germans. I was 5 and my sister, 6, and every night as we went to bed we said our prayers that Ronnie and Donnie would return safely. Thank God, they survived and came home to lead meaningful lives, never forgetting their service, their country, or our democracy. Thank you, Marianne and George, for exquisitively never forgetting.
GV
6/6/2024 10:16:49 pm
Chief, thank you for telling me about your relatives...and thanks to them for their service. G
Randolph
6/7/2024 05:35:05 am
George,
Jean
6/7/2024 11:34:25 am
I have seen the graves . In Flanders field the popies grow neath the crosses row on row
bruce
6/7/2024 12:40:19 pm
george,
Randolph
6/7/2024 04:03:25 pm
George,
Randolph
6/7/2024 04:05:14 pm
Roger Cohen….. autocorrect drives me crazy.
Alan D. Levine
6/9/2024 02:56:22 pm
The war effort was enormous. People were assigned to all sorts of jobs--everywhere. Where you ended up could have a lot to do with luck (yours) and the army's needs. My cousin Lester, a Jewish kid from Queens who I don't think had ever been in an airplane before he was drafted, did so well in flight school, that they wouldn't let him see combat. He was designated a flight instructor and spent the whole war in Texas, teaching other people to fly. Comments are closed.
|
Categories
All
|