Ted Cruz, the lawyer who scorns election ambiguities and disclosure rules, also scorns “New York values.”
We know what Cruz is doing – going after the evangelical vote by raising that old specter, the urban type, with noses and accents and odd names and weird food tastes. You know. The city where America’s children go if they think they can make it there. Cruz was going after Donald Trump – and welcome to that – by making him typical of New York. But as somebody who grew up a crucial half mile from the Trumps, I have to admit, the Donald, in his own vulgar way, represents a sub-group, his home borough of Queens. Simon & Garfunkel. 50 Cent. My Jamaica High chorus members, The Cleftones, who played PAL basketball for the 103rd Precinct. Bernadette Peters. And I remember my friend’s older sister, when I was 10 or so, raving about “that Tony Benedetto from Astoria”. The man is still singing, but now to Lady Gaga. Many of us from Queens form a yappy lot. Is it the vital separation from “The City” – Manhattan? Looie Carnesecca, for many years from Jamaica Estates, says New York pizza is the best because of the water. Is it the brackish water of Flushing Bay and Jamaica Bay and Newtown Creek that makes Queens people tend to mouth off? Or is it the relative space and light that grows characters? John McEnroe. Jimmy Breslin. Howard Stern. Fran Drescher. Christopher Walken. Trump is a mouthy rich boy, but Cruz prodded him into the first dignified moment of his campaign, maybe of his life. Trump stuck up for us, the people with the New York values. Athletes? The common ingredient of Queens jocks is the need to handle the ball. Point guards. Control freaks. Bob Cousy-Dick McGuire-Kenny Anderson-Kenny Smith- Mark Jackson-Nancy Lieberman, who took the A train from Far Rockaway to Harlem to get a game. Peter Vecsey, who played for Molloy and writes about hoopsters. And from Jamaica High and St. John’s, Alan Seiden, known in the P.S. 26 schoolyard as “And One,” because he called a foul every time he took a shot. Bob Beamon, from Jamaica High, was a dunker, not a passer. He could leap. Leaped to a world long jump record in Mexico in 1968. The thing about Queens is that the subway and elevated lines all head west, toward The City. I remember slouching in class at JHS 157 in Rego Park, watching the No. 7 El rumble toward The City. Trump lived a few blocks from the last stop on the F Line but I wouldn’t bet he ever took the train. Probably got chauffeured to his prep schools. With all this glorious diversity around him, somewhere along the line Trump developed outsize prejudices. This tells me he never spent much time with Me and Julio Down by the Schoolyard. He would have a different facial look if he had. Queens College graduates: Jerry Seinfeld. Ray Romano. Howie Rose, Mets voice. Cruz is playing to the base, the red-hots who cheered him in South Carolina and might caucus for him in Iowa on Feb. 1. His code words of “New York values” are an insult to the Chinese in Flushing and the Koreans along Northern Blvd. and the Latinos around 82nd St. and the South Asians around 74th St. -- and my friend Alton Gibson from South Jamaica who disregarded his guidance counselor’s advice to take vocational classes, and got himself advanced degrees and a good career. Those New York values. Mario Cuomo from South Jamaica who married the beautiful Matilda Raffa and led a life of good works and talented children. In Queens, we talk and write and sing and dream. Letty Cottin Pogrebin. Stephen Jay Gould. Stephen Dunn, zone-busting guard and Pulitzer Prize winning poet. Francis Ford Coppola. Sam Toperoff. Lucy Liu. Russell Simmons. Idina Menzel. Michael Landon. Cyndi Lauper. Joe Austin, Mario Cuomo’s coach for life. The bright young woman from the English class in Jamaica High a decade ago, now a college graduate doing advance work for Bernie Sanders in New Hampshire. The bright young woman from two decades ago, now getting her teaching certificate in the grand building on the hill. Those voices Those accents. The great spices emanating from open doors and adjacent apartments in Astoria and Bayside and Hollis and Ozone Park. The dreams. The drives. The New York values. 1/17/2016 11:58:29 am
Nice to see Trunp defend "New York" values. Even a broken clock is correct twice a day.
Shelley Braunstein
1/17/2016 12:40:38 pm
I loved the column. Yes, New York is a hotbed of creativity, talent, cosmopolitanism and readiness to engage with the wider world.
George Vecsey
1/17/2016 03:55:30 pm
Alan, I didn't mention Messrs. Rizzuto and Ford, either.
George Vecsey
1/17/2016 03:58:40 pm
Shelley, nice to hear from you. You made it to The City.
Ed Martin
1/21/2016 10:03:57 pm
Alan, I used to listen to my radio every night: boxing from St. Nicholas Arena, college basketball, the Knicks, the Rangers, Friday night boxing from MSG and the track and field, Millrose Games, Wanamaker Mile, and names like poetry, Harrison Dillard from Baldwin Wallace. I notice by the way that Cruz went to two Ivy League colleges and is married to an investment banker at Goldman Sachs. New York values?
Eddie Lewin
1/17/2016 05:32:59 pm
The truth from your observations and opinions ring as clearly as Saint Patty's bells on Sunday! To have grown up in that environment, received a wonderful education at Jamaica HS, to have been the only white boy invited to join the Cleftones in hall-singing, all in a relatively safe and joyful environment provided a platform to move on to special things in life. I could not imagine more joy than growning up as a "New Yorker" so denigrated by Mr. Cruz.
George Vecsey
1/17/2016 06:01:19 pm
Outstanding soccer halfback.
Brian Savin
1/17/2016 08:06:52 pm
I'm fascinated (maybe a bit disgusted) with myself about how your post appeals to my gut, George. I hate 'em both, but if Sophie's Choice were forced on me, I'd hand 'em Cruz.
George Vecsey
1/18/2016 10:10:24 am
Brian: I go with Mercutio:
Brian Savin
1/18/2016 10:24:12 am
Yeah, wherefore art thou, Romeo? Or Juliet? Not this year. Bernie as Prince Escalus? A stretch, but I'll take it.
Sam Toperoff
1/18/2016 10:35:55 am
After reading your fine essay, I took out a DVD of "New York The Way It Was: Queens." Your piece prompted me to take it out. There you were on camera saying the same good stuff twenty years ago. But there was also Carrol O'Connor, Mario Cuomo, Bob Cousy, Mr. Steinway, Grace Shulman, et al. Louis Armstrong, I recall, lived in Corona. There was Dexter Park, where black and white baseball players took the same field years before Jackie Robinson. And there, too, on screen was a young Trump, talking about his father's post-War success in the home-building market boom that started their fortunes. At the end of the show, Mario Cuomo says, "It was growing up in Queens that introduced me to the beautiful mix of people that prepared me for the real world." Indeed, the real world!
Andy Tansey
1/20/2016 07:47:27 am
I shall, naturally, follow the Archbishop Molloy HS ("Stanners")thread. I could not verify it from here, but I have heard that Carroll O'Connor attended its predecessor in Manhattan, St. Ann's Academy, perhaps in the elementary school; I see he graduated from Newtown HS. Ray Romano also attended but did not graduate from Molloy, as did Vitas Gerulaitis. Our current governor is a Stanner.
Brian Savin
1/18/2016 10:42:35 am
Sam, Cruz is not their favorite. They have no favorite except to be there for the one in power. They are huge money-throwing fans of Hillary, too. Bernie, they don't like so much, and he went out of his way yesterday to make sure that doesn't change. Our system is just plain broken and bought.
George Vecsey
1/18/2016 11:52:41 am
Sam from the Alps, meet Brian from the Berkshires.
Brian Savin
1/18/2016 11:18:28 am
Fun facts for all you Queenslings: I believe you were shut out in this year's NFL playoffs. I may be wrong, but I can't find a single player born in Queens on any of the four surviving rosters. There have been many NFL players born in Queens, however. Here's an argument to pick:
George Vecsey
1/18/2016 11:49:12 am
Rentzel, didn't know he was born in Queens. 1/18/2016 12:19:04 pm
Today, people from Queens have enough sense not to play pro football. 1/18/2016 02:51:50 pm
George, I saw your talents at Halsey, and they continued at Jamaica and then Hofstra. Who thought you would make it in the Big Apple. Anyway, great job. You are hitting 1000.
George Vecsey
1/18/2016 03:28:42 pm
Stanley: welcome back and thanks. Just heard from a few of your Halsey pals. We did all right for outer-borough types. Too bad Cruz doesn't like our values. Then again, I don't like his. GV
bruce
1/18/2016 11:21:38 pm
George,
George Vecsey
1/19/2016 08:32:53 am
Bruce: got nothing bad to say about Calgary. Had a great time at 1988 Winter Olympics. Wrote a column about the ultimate Big Chinook (hot wind) arriving -- George Steinbrenner. Mountie (in car) let me off with warning when I was doing 85 to get to see Lake Louise before sundown Gorgeous. Cruz has great roots -- Cuba, Calgary. Where did he pick up his Joe McCarthy nastiness? GV
bruce
1/19/2016 09:10:16 am
geroge,
Alan D. Levine
1/19/2016 12:22:28 pm
Did you see that terrific editorial in the Daily News Saturday? It said that a careful reading of Cruz's comments makes it seem as if he wants to substitute a J for the N in our city's name. And when did the Daily News cease being a fascist rag anyway?
George Vecsey
1/19/2016 01:27:44 pm
Alan, it's moved away from the Daily News we remember (and where I worked summers 56-57) a while ago. When I was a cityside reporter in the 70s, the Daily News did a great job --plus voices like Lars-Erik Nelson (died way too young), Pete Hamill and Bob Herbert (who went to the NYT) It's a shame to watch the Daily News give up, recently dismissing some of the best writers on its sports staff, plus an editor who led the investigations. Having Murdoch in NY freed the Daily News to be more populist. (Ford to NY, etc.)
Josh Rubin
1/19/2016 02:03:06 pm
I have nothing to add to the Queens Hall of Fame assembled in this thread. But Cruz's attack, and Trump's defense, of New York values, and particularly Trump's invocation of 9/11 and how the City stood together, reminded me of the firefighters who went up into the towers after the towers were hit. They went up out of a tremendous sense of duty, saved as many lives as they could, and many lost their own and probably went up knowing they were not likely to see daylight again. I've gone back and listened to Springsteen's "Into the Fire" -- a somber and heartbreaking benediction for New York's bravest. Now those are some real New York values.
George Vecsey
1/19/2016 03:17:47 pm
Josh, thanks for bringing my musings back toward the real point. We are real people all over New York -- worship, families, daily life much like anywhere else. Cruz blurted out the dog whistle code to his people.
Although Mayor Guilaini received considerable credit for his actions during 9/11, I consider him a villain. He would not allow rescue workers to wear protective face masks as he did not want any show of danger. This was true for all individuals entering ground zero.
Brian Savin
1/19/2016 05:12:22 pm
Alan D, I never heard such a thing. Do you have a citation you could share for that accusation? I've looked some and can't find anything. Thanks much.
Alan D. Levine
1/19/2016 05:50:11 pm
Brian--That's not me. It's Alan Rubin.
Alan Rubin
1/19/2016 08:57:41 pm
Brian--This is an exert from the following link:
Brian Savin
1/20/2016 09:09:12 am
Alan,
George Vecsey
1/20/2016 01:03:00 pm
Brian, Alan, anybody else:
bruce
1/20/2016 01:18:28 pm
George,
George Vecsey
1/21/2016 08:34:47 am
Bruce, the NYT web site (and paper) does regularly challenge statements, sometimes quite wittily. But usually within a Fact-Checker format. Stories tend to be more straight. But you are right. Politicians say stuff, playing to religious and political beliefs, and people go for it. 1/21/2016 02:47:45 am
Keep up the good work, and post more articles like the one you have posted above. Very interesting and also informative. 12/21/2016 09:50:15 pm
Every thing is good. But if you run a blog, you should add a about me page that will directly connect you to your visitors. Comments are closed.
|
Categories
All
|