Reviews

Is Football Bad for the Brain -- Ours Included?

9/12/2014

The study does not include fans. Photo via PBS/Frontline

For those of you about to watch a little football over the weekend, does the "sport" induce brain damage not only to the players but also to the viewers?

After a weekend of listening to the blather on the tube, many viewers tend to believe that “college” players are really student-athletes and that NFL players can step back into society on Sunday evening after a week, after a near lifetime, of banging heads.

The Ray Rice case probably should cost Commissioner Roger Goodell his job one of these days. Hearing the report that Rice had dragged his girlfriend, now his wife, out of an elevator after “rendering her unconscious” did not arouse any curiosity in Goodell. Biff-bam-pow. It sounded like one of those phrases John Madden and the lads used to chortle on the compliant networks not so long ago.

“Got his bell rung.”

X-rays of autopsies to follow.

Just think about it while watching the “amateurs” and the “professionals:" the know-nothing impulse of Goodell and his league regarding Ray Rice and now-wife is not the first or perhaps most widespread scandal facing the NFL.

These people have been ducking the clear evidence of damaged players for generations. Men had their uniforms taken away when they could no longer compete, and soon afterward an alarming number had another clubhouse - a rest home with burly attendants to care for them.

For many years the NFL relied for brain advice on its medical advisor, Dr. Elliot Pellman, who was not an expert in neurology, and who resigned in 2007 after articles by Alan Schwarz in The New York Times and other sources.

http://www.nytimes.com/2010/06/02/sports/football/02concussion.html

I had already posted this article when things got worse. The front-page story in the Times by Ken Belson said the NFL is admitting that one-third of its former players are likely to have brain damage. In case you missed it:

http://www.nytimes.com/2014/09/13/sports/football/actuarial-reports-in-nfl-concussion-deal-are-released.html?_r=0

Until recently, the NFL's position was that players did not have brain damage. Rather, they were rendered unconscious. Big difference.

What happens to players still getting hit early and often by other behemoths? Do they left-hook their companions, or strangers, and dump them halfway out of an elevator and nudge them with their feet?

At the moment that ugly video surfaced, the two NFL scandals were joined. Does football make players violent long before brain damage is confirmed -- via an autopsy?

Have a nice violent weekend.

Michael Green

9/13/2014 06:35:04 am

As I recall, there was a big push for Schwarz to win the Pulitzer for his reporting on this. I suspect he deserved it.

One of the best descriptions of being a football player that I have read was by, believe it or not, Ron Luciano, the comedic umpire, in one of his books. Remember that he was in the NFL and AFL. He talked about how each day, he was in just a little less pain as the week went on. He meant it to be funny, I gather, but it also was painful to read.

George Vecsey

9/13/2014 09:18:53 am

Remember the opening scene in North Dallas Forty? Player reaching for his pills, Monday morning.

Everybody knows. Owners. Sponsors. Networks. Doctors. It's the Colosseum.

Broken athletes and their families.

GV

mike from whitestone

9/13/2014 07:09:46 am

Touchdown GV.

Now Peterson might trump Rice. How sad.

Great year for coverups in the NBA and NFL.

Au revoir Roger.....

George Vecsey

9/13/2014 09:17:12 am

The owners love a guy who makes them money.
Until he becomes inconvenient.

GV

Alan Rubin link

9/13/2014 11:24:46 am

Today, things are often being relabeled the new” this” or the new “that”—eighty is the new sixty, or in the HBO show Orange is the New Black.

One might conclude from the recent publicity concerning the NFL, both on the playing field and domestically; that violence is the new norm.

Sadly, it has been around almost forever and the only thing new is the intense media attention and a growing outrage over brain injuries and the physical abuse of women.

I never realized how brutal football really was until I read former Green Bay Packer lineman Jerry Kramer’s 1967 book, “Instant Replay”. He described playing through pain and how as the season progressed he was barely able to play the following Sunday.

Sometime later there was a story about the majority of retired NFL players having disabilities, many crippling.

Joanna Weiss’ recent article in the Boston Globe, ”Ray Rice and domestic violence: No isn’t enough” is an excellent read.

http://www.bostonglobe.com/opinion/2014/09/12/ray-rice-and-domestic-violence-isn-enough/gcQrCWqn03mLdjAGX9UaKN/story.html

I find it difficult to comprehend the ability of NFL owners to accept all the physical and mental damage that is considered part of the game, and that so many fans expect and relish it.

I suspect that the money is just too great.

At a senate subcommittee hearing on June 9, 1954 Boston lawyer Joseph Walsh commented to Senator Joe McCarthy, “Until this moment, Senator, I think I never really gauged your cruelty or your recklessness.” He then followed with his famous comment. “Have you no sense of decency?"

Both of Walsh’s comments apply to the NFL today.

George Vecsey

9/13/2014 12:24:28 pm

I remember Jos. Welch's remarks to McCarthy -- turning point.
I'm sure the owners know.
But also, players play of their own volition -- the money is good, and so is the fame, the trappings. Free volition and all that....
But only now are they learning the facts.
Even former NFL players have doubts about letting their sons play.

GV

Craig N. Oren

9/14/2014 02:20:33 pm

just can't stand to watch football any more -- a sport that's given me many exciting moments over the years. I confess I skim the coverage in the newspaper, but don't watch or go to any games. And there are plenty of other things to do on a Sunday afternoon.

Brian Savin

9/15/2014 01:34:29 am

This piece is the Joe Friday kernel of it all -- straight, short, and posing the relevant question in a way that wraps it all up. The rest is commentary.

9/15/2014 01:37:19 am

Good to hear from both of you.

I think football became a cliche years ago -- all looks and sounds the same. But the evidence mounts that football is dangerous -- on the field and off. The quote from Rep. Sanchez in Alan Schwarz' article today indicates how transparent the NFL arrogance is. She picked up on it right away. Met her at a few Congressional hearings, one of the best.

GV

Gene Palumbo

9/17/2014 01:11:08 pm

In a comment above, George wrote, "Even former NFL players have doubts about letting their sons play."

And former college players, too:

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/11/08/sports/ncaafootball/jordan-wynn-utahs-22-year-old-retiree-contemplates-the-future.html

The 22-Year-Old Retiree
By GREG BISHOP

. . . A sling, a maze of straps and buckles, stabilized [Jordan Wynn's] left arm. That is the bionic one. . . When he played quarterback at Utah, before the injuries and the operations, before the sympathy and the pity, before he retired at 22, some of the best moments of Wynn’s life occurred in that very end zone.. . .

“That was the beginning,” he said. “This is the end.”

On his cellphone, Wynn loaded a picture of an X-ray. It was his left shoulder, the labrum torn all the way around. Staples now hold it in place, along with a pair of three-inch screws and a piece of collarbone.. . .

After four operations — three on the left shoulder, one on the right — after one shoulder or the other popped out of joint close to 100 times, Wynn retired this fall. . . .

Wynn loved football, loved Utah, loved his starring turn. But the more he talked inside a pizza joint near campus decorated with posters of the Beatles and old-school Utah Jazz pennants, the more he seemed to embody football’s current crossroads. He did not appear bitter over his predicament, only sad and realistic.

As he bit into a pepperoni slice, Wynn said: “I’m not going to let my kid play football. No way. I’m going to show him that picture, my screws. I’m going to put a putter in the crib.”

Happy new year sms link

12/28/2014 10:45:54 pm

Really awesome article about Happy new year messages 2015.i appreciate your idea.Thank you so much for sharing nice collection of happy new year quotes.i like your post and happy new year in advance!!
<a href=" http://happynewyearsms.net/happy-new-year-messages/">Happy New Year Messages</a>

happy new year images 2016 link

12/31/2015 05:17:15 am

Great blog

junaid link

1/14/2016 01:02:32 pm

Valentine's Day, <a href="http://happyvalentinesdayimages2016p.com/">happy valentines day images 2016 pictures wallpapers</a> It is celebrated in many countries around the world.

Comments are closed.

Is Football Bad for the Brain -- Ours Included?

Categories

Buy the Book