The hissy fit by Amazon reminds me of one of the best things that has happened to my home town -- not getting the 2012 Summer Olympics. This happened in 2005, when the City Council voted down a stadium that would have been plopped down on the far west side of Manhattan to accommodate the Typhoid Mary of sports events. Since the Games were given to London, the Hudson Yards area of Manhattan has grown, without having to work around a neighborhood killer of a stadium. I say that as a sports columnist who was a very early critic of the proposal. My memory was just jogged by the rising up of people who resented the $3-billion tax benefits to be given Amazon, which wanted to build a “campus” in the Long Island City section of Queens. Rather than negotiate with critics – show some respect for the locals -- Amazon turned tail and ran. The political aspects have been well reported in the Times and elsewhere. Experts and business people say Amazon really would have meant 25,000 new jobs in the city, but I say they would have been jobs for new people, out-of-towners, with technological skills, eager to pay the gouge prices in new high rises in formerly lumpen Queens. As David Leonhardt points out, Queens already has jobs: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/02/17/opinion/amazon-new-york.html As a native of Queens (who lives just to the east these days), I love the boom all over my home borough -- the languages and energy and skills and food: Oaxaca restaurant in Corona; Korean restaurants along Northern Blvd. I’m not sure Queens needs the great favor Amazon was going to bestow. Many people living near the proposed “campus” would have been displaced by the land rush and the rent-grubbing and the price-raising. (See: “Brooklyn, hipsters.”) To Jeff Bezos, I would say a few things: 1. Thank you for the Prime delivery of a 64-ounce container of kitchen-drain cleaner rather than my having to run to the store during the deep freeze this month. 2. Please, keep reporting on that disturbed person in Washington with your wonderful paper, The Washington Post. 3. When local activists express their concerns, please, learn to negotiate. This is Noo Yawk, for goodness’ sakes. (“If I can make it there, I’ll make it anywhere.” Guess you didn’t.) 4. And while I think of it, please read your own paper’s electronic files about the stupidity of people who take intimate selfies. This uprising by “progressives” – whatever that means – seems to have come as a shock to Gov. Cuomo and Mayor DiBlasio (who keeps changing his story, as in his 180-degree swerve in the Times on Monday.) I would give some advice to these illustrious public servants. (The same would apply to former mayors Bloomberg and Giuliani.) 1. Fix the damn subways first. Help working people get to work. 2. Pay attention to the rising seas, because the disturbed President has no clue. 3. Pay attention to those dreaded “progressives.” These guys are always running for President rather than fixing New York. They need to know that New Yorkers don’t like out-of-towners telling us what the deal is. Jeff Bezos, say hello to the New York Echo: Visitor: Hello-o-o-o-o! New York Echo: Shut the f--k u-u-u-u-p! ------ *-Homage to the greatest headline any of us will ever see, written by William J. Brink, managing editor of the New York Daily News, when President Ford did not help the city during the 1975 financial crisis: FORD TO CITY: DROP DEAD.
bruce
2/18/2019 10:51:25 am
george,
George Vecsey
2/18/2019 11:21:58 am
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/02/16/opinion/sunday/queens-amazon.html
bruce
2/18/2019 12:40:29 pm
george,
Hansen Alexander
2/18/2019 02:47:14 pm
George, I'm going to have to disagree with you on the Amazon issue, even though you grew up in Queens, and know vastly more than I do about the LIC area. Hell, you probably know vastly more about the actual details of the Amazon contract than I do. However, the horror stories about massive rent increases to come, the unfairness of a $3 billion tax incentive, and alleged physical debasement of the neighborhood, was not backed up be enough hard evidence to sway this lawyer against the plan. It looks to me as it served mostly as a launching pad for the political careers of progressives on the make. 25,000 jobs is nothing to snear at, particularly from a well managed company that would have easily realized an instant return on the investment of that $3 billion, unlike Governor Cuomo's tax giveaway to out of state companies to open for business in New York State, which has actually LOST the state money. As I understand it, the shrill claims of Amazon's union-busting intentions, is not backed by any evidence, at least as far as Queens goes, as these jobs are either management or high tech, not usually areas of unionization in the Brave New World of an interdependent, world economy.
George Vecsey
2/18/2019 06:54:58 pm
Hansen: Thanks, I get everything you say, and have read them from others who know business/law/politics better than I do. I know people who work and teach in that neighborhood who wonder if people will be forced to move further from schools and work in LI City because of the land rush and the rent hikes. I don't believe Amazon that there will be jobs for people in the Queensbridge buildings. I was surprised by the "Progressives" who flexed muscles, vocal chords, etc -- part of the reaction to the Trump age, probably. Doubt I would have jumped on this issue if Amazon hadn't run at the sign of conflict, the poor dears. Thanks for your realistic input. The 25,000 jobs sounded great...Best, George
Roy Edelsack
2/18/2019 12:42:39 pm
The greatest headline I ever saw on the sports pages of the NY Post was an appreciation of the long career of steeplechase trainer Burley Cocks:
bruce
2/18/2019 12:56:43 pm
roy,
bruce
2/18/2019 12:47:50 pm
roy,
Jeff Geller
2/18/2019 10:34:43 pm
With all the statements about the deal flying, pardon the expression, from the left and right, I keep thinking about what Claude Rains would have said about all this, 'I am shock, shock about how this agreement unraveled' This coming from a guy who walked a long block and a quarter to the Parsons Blvd IND station to go to The City.
George Vecsey
2/20/2019 02:06:56 pm
Jeff, know that corner well. at the bottom of the glacial hill. I recall a trolley line running from Hillside up to Horace Harding around 1950....I used to take it to a Saturday "enrichment" class for kids at Queens College. And near Jamaica was the old library. Our own little world. 2/19/2019 05:51:04 pm
All too often, the financial incentives for companies to invest in communities do not bring the desired benefit.
Ed Martin
2/19/2019 08:46:38 pm
George for President!!
bruce
2/19/2019 08:51:37 pm
ed,
Herb Chasman
2/23/2019 10:04:42 pm
Spent my formative years in Queens at P.S. 26 (lights in the school yard at night did not draw flies but did draw basketball players from all over the City) and Jamaica High during the glory years,1952 to 1956.
Hillel Kuttler
2/24/2019 03:31:53 am
Couldn't the ghost of Casey Stengel sue Jeff Bezos's company for expropriating The Old Perfessor's famed Mets adjective? Comments are closed.
|
Categories
All
|