The good guys won.
Nobody knows how much of the $148-million will ultimately go to Ruby Freeman and her daughter, Shaye Moss. But in a disheartening time of legal stalling, when it looks like the United States cannot protect itself from those who would tear it apart, at least mother and daughter have been awarded an astounding judgment against Rudy Giuliani. The broken-down bully calculated that he could charge the poll workers with trying to swing the 2020 election, if he used the stereotype of Black criminality. Was this Rudy Giuliani all along? Did he build his career as public prosecutor on bashing the minorities? Was he playing to white prejudices – bragging about busting the squeegee guys who tried to clean windshields for quarters on the clogged streets of Manhattan? Our hero. Protecting us. But he wasn’t smart enough when he stuck government offices near the Twin Towers, already threatened by violence. Was he ever anything more than a mirror image of the racist punk he served, who grew up on Midland Parkway in posh Jamaica Estates? They knew the white buttons to press. Bullies know this stuff. Like in the 2016 campaign when Trump pointed out a Black heckler and, from a safe distance, Trump made a heroic punching gesture and said he would love to…. Big man. Playing to the racists who have come out from under the rocks. (Plus, American anti-Semites who have dragged out their inbred prejudices during about the violence in the Middle East. It never went away.) As for domestic politics: Rigged election? Let’s pick on the Black women. But these Black women had something on their side – faith and resolution. When they testified at the Jan. 6 hearings, they were a monument of righteousness. The mother, Ruby, sat at her daughter’s shoulder, willing her strength, a reverse-gender Pietà. And those two women were flanked by officers who had been heroes in protecting the Congress on that horrible day -- big Harry Dunn and his colleagues. On Friday, outside a courtroom in DC, the mother and daughter seemed happily stunned by the jury decision. They were not spending a penny of it, inasmuch as Rudy may very well be poor. Plus, what is the cost of the two women hearing Trumpite footsteps and seeing Rudy shadows for a long time? But the church ladies were cheered by the legal support, and when they made their statements they did not gloat. In fact, they witnessed their faith on the sidewalk – street preachers, the resolution one hears at the Black churches. They can’t exactly go home again. Too many bad people out there. But they could get in a protected auto and leave the sidewalk to a broken-down former prosecutor, on a perp walk, his role now reversed. I used to know Rudy Giuliani – Yankee fan, America’s mayor who stood up big when the airplanes hit us. He was everywhere that terrible autumn, walking with the cops and the firemen and the priests on the narrow streets of downtown. And in his spare time, he went to root for his Yankees as they advanced to the World Series. Not even two months after the attack, Giuliani managed to follow the Yankees to games in Arizona. He was an appealing figure, waiting with reporters for the clubhouse doors to open. “You’re crazy,” I said to a man operating without sleep, on sheer nerve. “Yeah,” Giuliani would admit with a weary smile. And nobody would deny him the cross-country flights, just for a few hours of rooting, normalcy. Eventually, he signed up to serve the bully, the bigot, the liar, who somehow became president. Instead of rooting for the fabled Yankees, Giuliani was now leading the cheers, giving terrible advice to a real-estate phony. They deserved each other, as Billy Martin once said about a much less important issue. Giuliani knew the formula. Blame the Black women. Now he is an old, feeble man, with the shakes, rumors of drinking, his teeth sticking out of his mouth, Rudy the Fool, but still capable of sounding like Rudy the Prosecutor. The truth will come out, he said on the sidewalk on Friday, but instead, guile seemed to ooze out of him, like hair dye on a hot summer day. He used to go after the squeegee guys. Then he served Trump, the real-estate exaggerator. Then he tried to bash church ladies. Bad move, dude.
Irwin Sollinger
12/16/2023 11:01:06 am
Well said!
Alan D. Levine
12/16/2023 11:26:14 am
First, in the Times tradition, a correction: The NYC Office of Emergency Management--now helmed by the son of our JHS classmate Ken Iscoll--was not located in the twin towers. It was down the block at 7 World Trade Center.
GV
12/16/2023 02:11:59 pm
Three members of the same graduating class from the late, great Jamaica High School responded to an entry by a four graduate. (Third quadrant, baby!) Alan, thanks for noticing. I changed it to "near." Funny how the folks who gravitate to this little therapy website have been storing up Rudy stories over the decades.
John McDermott
12/16/2023 11:42:06 am
A good day. I wish my friend Bob Wallach were still alive to see it. Giuliani prosecuted and relentlessly persecuted Bob in the 1980's, and nearly bankrupted him. Bob's best friend was Ed Meese and Giuliani was trying to get to Meese by pressuring Bob. Bob-a legendary San Francisco lawyer and former US Ambassador to the the UN Human Rights Commission-had done nothing wrong and was ultimately absolved able to recover his law practice. But Giuliani was never held to account for what was a serious abuse of prosecutorial power.
Walter Schwartz
12/16/2023 12:14:09 pm
It's likely all of us, including myself, who have been around long enough, have been fooled at least once by slick politicians, but I'm proud to say I was never fooled by Rudolph Giuliani, who years ago made an immediate and consistent impression upon me as a bully who mistreated those over whom he could exercise the upper hand: wives and x-wives, the press, and defendants who hadn't been tried or convicted, just to name a few categories. He gravitated to the Bernie Keriks and Donald Trumps, and a lot of other people who felt the law should be changed to give him a third term after 911 so he could become king. Now, instead, he's become court jester.
Randolph
12/16/2023 12:58:10 pm
George,
Ed Martin
12/16/2023 01:19:50 pm
Even the NYPD figured him out. One of our sons, was walking down a street east of City Hall, a group protesting some Giuliani attack, perhaps on the Brooklyn Museum where he found a work of art didn’t suit him and he wanted to cut their funding (city council did not go along). The police had cut off the sidewalk across the street, making it impossible to use, nowhere near the site. Son spoke to officer about the restrictions on citizens not involved. The LEO said with a kind of sneer as he turned away, “Tell it to Guiliani.” 12/16/2023 01:36:53 pm
As a native Manhattanite and a longtime resident of the Upper Westside, I was able to observe Giuliani and Trump up close. Both were shady opportunists who deceived the public.
Jean Grenning APLS
12/16/2023 04:22:37 pm
Excellent!!
RICHARD TAYLOR
12/16/2023 07:36:32 pm
George, I am so pleased you continue to write.
Altenir Silva
12/16/2023 07:52:06 pm
Hi George,
Gene Palumbo
12/19/2023 01:43:41 pm
I had the great good fortune to have Wayne Barrett as a friend. I was happy to see Alan Levine’s reference to him: “I wish Wayne Barrett were still alive to write a second volume of his perfect biography of [Giuliani].” Me too. To get a taste (that is, the first eight pages) of Wayne’s (and Dan Collins’) “Grand Illusion: The Untold Story of Rudy Giuliani and 9/11,” go here:
bruce
12/20/2023 12:03:21 am
gene,
bruce
12/20/2023 12:33:23 am
gene,
Alan D. Levine
12/19/2023 01:57:47 pm
It was the second book you mentioned that I was referring to Gene. I didn't know about the other one. I'm going to get it.
bruce
12/19/2023 11:58:36 pm
george, Comments are closed.
|
Categories
All
|